Perencanaan Bergaransi : Jawaban Atas Kritik Partisipasi Publik

I hurried into the local department CCNA 200-125 Practice Test Questions store to grab1 some last minute Chirsmas gifts. Bestexamview 300-208 Practice Test I looked at all the people and grumbled2 to myself. 300-208 Practice Test I would be in here forever and CCNA 200-125 Practice Test Questions I just 300-208 Practice Test Examtestview had so much to do. Chirsmas was Cisco 300-070 pdf beginning to become Cisco 300-070 pdf such a drag. I kinda 70-346 exam questions wished that I could just sleep through Chirsmas. But I 1Z0-062 study guide pdf hurried the Bestexamview best I could through all the 300-208 Practice Test people to the toy department. Once again I kind of mumbled3 to myself at the prices of all these toys, and wondered Examtestview if the grandkids would even play 1Z0-062 study guide pdf 1Z0-062 study guide pdf whit4 them. I found myself in the doll aisle5. Out of the 70-346 exam questions corner of my eye I saw a little boy about 5 holding a lovely CCNA 200-125 Practice Test Questions doll.He kept touching6 her hair Cisco 300-070 pdf and he held 300-208 Practice Test her so gently. I could not seem to help myself. I just CCNA 200-125 Practice Test Questions kept loking over at 70-346 exam questions the little 70-346 exam questions boy and wondered who the doll was Cisco 300-070 pdf for. I 1Z0-062 study guide pdf watched him turn to a 70-346 exam questions woman and he called 300-208 Practice Test his Bestexamview 70-412 exam questions aunt by name and said, “Are you sure I don’t have enough Bestexamview money?” Cisco 300-070 pdf She replied a bit impatiently, “You know that you don’t have enough CCNA 200-125 Practice Test Questions CCNA 200-125 Practice Test Questions money for it.” The aunt told the little Bestexamview boy not to go anywhere Bestexamview that she had to go and get some other things and 70-412 exam questions would be back in a few minutes. And then she left CCNA 200-125 Practice Test Questions Bestexamview the aisle. The boy continued to hold the doll. After a bit Cisco 300-070 pdf 70-346 exam questions Bestexamview I asked the boy who the doll was 300-208 Practice Test 70-346 exam questions for. He said, “It is the doll my sister wanted so Cisco 300-070 pdf Cisco 300-070 pdf badly for Chirsmas. She just knew that Santa would bring Bestexamview it. “I told him that Examtestview 70-412 exam questions maybe Santa 1Z0-062 study guide pdf was going to bring it . He said, “No, Bestexamview Santa can’t go where my sister Examtestview Examtestview 70-412 exam questions is…. 1Z0-062 study guide pdf I have to 70-412 exam questions give the doll to my Mama to take 70-412 exam questions 1Z0-062 study guide pdf to her. “I asked him where his 70-346 exam questions siter was. He looked at me with the saddest eyes and said, “She 70-412 exam questions was gone to be with Jesus.

My Daddy says CCNA 200-125 Practice Test Questions that Mamma is going to have to go be 70-412 exam questions with her.” My heart nearly stopped beating. Then the boy looked at me again and said, “I told my Daddy to tell my Cisco 300-070 pdf Mama not to go yet. I told CCNA 200-125 Practice Test Questions him to tell her to wait till I got back from the 300-208 Practice Test store.” Then he asked me Examtestview if i wanted to see his picture. CCNA 200-125 Practice Test Questions I told him I’d love to. He pulled out some picture he’d had taken at the 70-346 exam questions front of the store. He said, “I want 300-208 Practice Test my Mama to take this with her so the 70-346 exam questions dosen’t ever forget me. I 1Z0-062 study guide pdf love my Mama so very Bestexamview much and I Examtestview wish she dind not have to 300-208 Practice Test 70-412 exam questions leave me.But Daddy says she will need Examtestview to be with CCNA 200-125 Practice Test Questions my sister.” I saw that the 70-346 exam questions little boy had lowered his head and 70-412 exam questions had Bestexamview grown so qiuet. While he was not looking I reached into my purse and pilled out a handful Examtestview of bills. I asked the Cisco 300-070 pdf little boy, 70-412 exam questions “Shall we count that miney Cisco 300-070 pdf 300-208 Practice Test one 300-208 Practice Test more time?” He grew excited and said, “Yes,I 70-346 exam questions just Examtestview know it has to be enough.” So I slipped my money in with his and we began to count it . Of course it was plenty for the doll. 1Z0-062 study guide pdf 70-412 exam questions He softly said, “Thank you 70-346 exam questions Examtestview Jesus for giving me enough money.” Cisco 300-070 pdf 70-346 exam questions Then Examtestview the boy said, “I just CCNA 200-125 Practice Test Questions asked Jesus to give Examtestview me enough money to buy this doll so Mama can take it with 70-412 exam questions her to give my sister. And he heard 1Z0-062 study guide pdf my 300-208 Practice Test prayer. I 1Z0-062 study guide pdf 70-412 exam questions wanted to ask him give for enough to buy my Mama a white 1Z0-062 study guide pdf rose, but I didn’t ask him, but he gave me enough to buy the 300-208 Practice Test doll and a rose for CCNA 200-125 Practice Test Questions my Mama. She Cisco 300-070 pdf loves white rose so much. “In 300-208 Practice Test a few minutes Bestexamview the aunt came CCNA 200-125 Practice Test Questions back and Cisco 300-070 pdf I wheeled my cart away. I Examtestview 1Z0-062 study guide pdf could not keep from thinking about the little boy as I finished my shoppong in a ttally different Cisco 300-070 pdf spirit than when I had started. And I 1Z0-062 study guide pdf kept remembering a story I had seen in the newspaper several days earlier about a drunk Cisco 300-070 pdf driver hitting a car and killing7 70-346 exam questions a little girl and the Mother was in serious condition. The family was deciding on whether to 1Z0-062 study guide pdf remove the life support. Now surely this little boy did not belong with that story.Two days later I read Examtestview in the paper where the family had disconnected the life support and the young 1Z0-062 study guide pdf 70-346 exam questions 70-412 exam questions CCNA 200-125 Practice Test Questions woman had died. Bestexamview I could not forget the little boy and just kept wondering if the two were somehow connected. Later that Bestexamview day, 70-412 exam questions Examtestview I could 300-208 Practice Test CCNA 200-125 Practice Test Questions not help myself and I went out and bought aome white roses and took them to the funeral home where the yough woman was .And there she was holding a lovely white rose, the beautiful doll, and the picture of the little boy in the store. I left there in tears, thier life changed forever. The love that Bestexamview little boy had for his little sisiter and his mother was overwhel. And in a split8 second a drunk driver had ripped9 the life of that little boy to pieces.

Dalam era otonomi daerah melalui konsep pembangunan daerah, maka perencanaan dimaknai sebagai bagian penting dalam kegiatan pembangunan. Konsep desentralisasi yang melahirkan otonomi daerah membawa perubahan paradigma pembangunan dari perencanaan yang bersifat sentralistik menjadi perencanaan partisipatif. Perencanaan pembangunan partisipatif pada mulanya dipopulerkan oleh Korten (1984) yang menyebut istilah people centered development yang menekankan peningkatan potensi manusia. Berdasarkan pemahaman tersebut maka sudah sewajarnya bahwa pembangunan daerah mensyaratkan partisipasi masyarakat dalam tahap perencanaannya. Partisipasi masyarakat akan menguatkan tingkat kepercayaan (akuntabilitas) dan rasa kepemilikan masyarakat terhadap pemerintah daerah. Lebih lanjut menurut Conyers (1994) mengemukakan 3 alasan utama mengapa partisipasi masyarakat dalam pembangunan menjadi penting: Pertama, masyarakat merupakan sumber informasi mengenai kondisi, kebutuhan dan sikap masyarakat setempat; Kedua, masyarakat akan lebih mempercayai program kegiatan pembangunan apabila mereka dilibatkan dalam persiapan dan perencanaannya karena meningkatnya pengetahuan masyarakat dan akan mempunyai rasa saling memiliki terhadap program; dan Ketiga, mendorong partisipasi umum karena timbul anggapan bahwa prinsip-prinsip demokrasi akan tercapai jika masyarakat dilibatkan dalam perencanaan. Vox populi vox dei (suara rakyat adalah suara Tuhan).

Dalam pelaksanaannya, partisipasi publik dalam perencanaan pembangunan daerah menemui berbagai kompleksitas permasalahan. Kenyataan di lapangan menunjukkan bahwa masyarakat hanya dimintai aspirasi-aspirasinya terutama kebutuhan-kebutuhan tanpa adanya feedback berupa jaminan. Terkesan formalitas partisipatif (Abe, 2005). Permasalahan tersebut terjadi di berbagai daerah di Indonesia. Dalam penelitiannya, Hastiyanto (2013) menyebutkan bahwa peran teknokratis pemerintah masih sangat besar dalam proses perencanaan pembangunan daerah. Masyarakat dilibatkan berpartisipasi namun tidak ada jaminan terhadap hasil partisipasi yang dilaksanakan pemerintah. Lebih lanjut, keputusan akhir dari partisipasi tetap berada di tangan elitis lokal yang belum tentu bisa mewakili kelompok masyarakat kelas bawah (Deviyanti, 2013; Wirawan, 2015). Dalam penelitian yang lain, Muluk (2007) juga menyimpulkan bahwa partisipasi masyarakat yang terjadi selama ini juga belum ideal dalam artian belum sampai pada derajat kendali warga (citizen control). Kendali warga akan memungkinkan masyarakat sebagai penentu tunggal penentuan kebijakan.

Disisi lain,  kelemahan krusial dari pelaksanaan partisipasi publik dalam perencanaan pembangunan daerah adalah rendahnya kesadaran dan kemampuan masyarakat untuk berpartisipasi. Menurut Muluk (2006) kesadaran berpartisipasi menyangkut kesiagsiagaan mental dan sikap untuk melakukan aktivitas berpartisipasi sedangkan kemampuan berpartisipasi dipengaruhi oleh tingkat SDM masyarakat. Rendahnya tingkat SDM juga berpengaruh pada tingkat kemampuan masyarakat untuk berperan aktif dalam perencanaan pembangunan daerah. Lebih lanjut Abe (2005) menambahkan bahwa selama proses transformasi kapasitas masyarakat dan keterampilan masyarakat tidak dilakukan, maka partisipasi hanya akan terlihat sebagai formalitas partisipatif sedangkan realitas sesungguhnya adalah hegemoni dan manipulasi. Untuk mengatasi permasalahan tersebut maka diperlukan keterbukaan pemerintah daerah untuk memberikan informasi yang seluas-luasnya kepada masyarakat tentang rencana yang akan disusun.

Sebenarnya masalah partisipasi bukan hanya bagaimana upaya membuka ruang partisipasi bagi publik tetapi juga bagaimana menindaklanjuti hasil partisipasi. Tidak ada jaminan terhadap usulan-usulan masyarakat dan dominannya eksekutif dalam forum akan menjadi formalitas partisipatif. Jaminan hasil partisipasi akan diakomodir dalam perencanaan pembangunan daerah itulah yang disebut dengan perencanaan bergaransi.

Menjawab berbagai kritik partisipasi publik terhadap pembangunan daerah, Bappedalitbang selaku institusi perencanaan di daerah memberikan ruang seluas-luasnya kepada masyarakat untuk berpartisipasi menentukan pembangunan daerahnya tidak hanya melalui forum resmi seperti Musrenbang. Komunitas Bagimu Trenggalek yang diketuai oleh M. Indra Setiawan langsung memberikan respon positif dengan membuat sebuah festival gagasan yang dapat diikuti oleh seluruh lapisan masyarakat bahkan PNS diperbolehkan untuk berpartisipasi mengemukakan gagasannya.

She just wants to sleep. The plane lasted two hours later, CISM Exam Dumps waiting for the luggage time dragged too long. The airport shuttle bus also missed the moment, the bus as early as an hour ago already drove away. So, they have to wait for a taxi now. Bestexamview She stood in the waiting line, slim body due to the weight of the laptop tilted to one side. John Examtestview talked about interest CISA dumps rates and new ideas for adjusting business CISM Exam Dumps partners, but she only thought of one thing it is Friday night at ten thirty, I want to wear pajamas, the United States and the United States to sleep. A yellow taxi endless stream passing her eyes. These cars are similar in color and shape, reminding Bestexamview her of insects. Cisco 210-260 Dumps She remembered her when he was a child in the mountains. When she and her brother spotted a broken badger or kicked a red ant nest, she saw a large group of limbs and Cisco 210-260 Dumps hands and feet wet wriggling on the ground. This chilling feeling made her shiver. A taxi speeding over, with a sharp brake sound abrupt halt. Tami Joan Kefas dragged forward. Driver press the trunk lock, but people did not move in the car. CISM Exam Dumps John was upset that they had to get CISA dumps their luggage on Bestexamview board. He is used to having others help him with these things. Tami Joan does Cisco 210-260 Dumps not matter. Until now, she occasionally will be surprised, I actually have a secretary, help Examtestview her typing and Examtestview file CISA dumps management. She threw the suitcase onto the car, closed the Cisco 210-260 Dumps trunk lid, and got into the car. John followed suit. He shut the door heavily, wiping his fat cheeks and his Cisco 210-260 Dumps bare forehead as hard as he had CISA dumps done with his luggage. First Bestexamview to East Cisco 210-260 Dumps 72nd Street. Cisco 210-260 Dumps Cisco 210-260 Dumps John murmured to the driver through the bulkhead. Then go to Upper West Side, Tami Joan added. Block the plexiglass partition between the front and rear seats covered with scratches, she could hardly see the driver. Taxi arrows rushed off the road and quickly ran up the highway to Manhattan. Look, Examtestview John said. Thats why people are everywhere today. He pointed to a Bestexamview billboard that read Welcome CISM Exam Dumps to the United Nations Peace Conference.

Further report. Criminal case found near railroad between 38th and 11th Street. Homicide. Completed. Criminal police, forensics, ambulance CISA dumps and emergency medical Finished. Received, 5885. Caught the suspect yet Finished. No suspects found. 5885, finished. Shakes looked at the finger, that root was Examtestview cut off the bones exposed bones finger. She looked at the glittering diamond ring, those eyes, and that twisted mouth Europe, that horrible mouth. Thriller spread throughout her body. Emilia Shakes swimming in the water snake river during the summer camp, and absolutely did not hesitate to jumped from the 100-foot bridge, but as long as she thought of a hush think of Bestexamview Was tied Examtestview into a ball, could not CISA dumps move, immediately fell into the feeling of panic like an electric shock. Because CISA dumps of this, Shakes walked so fast and was so crazy when driving. As long as you move, they can not catch you Examtestview She heard a voice and quickly looked up. A rumbling Examtestview CISA dumps sound came from far and louder and louder. Few CISM Exam Dumps CISM Exam Dumps pieces of shredded CISM Exam Dumps paper are CISA dumps raised by the wind and fly along the rails. Dust circling around her, like an angry ghost. Then there was a deep whine Emiliano Shakespear, a five-foot-nine patrolman, found himself facing the locomotive of a 31-ton American-American company. The red, white, blue-faced steel behemoth is approaching CISA dumps her at ten miles an hour. Stop Stop She shouted. The train driver ignored CISM Exam Dumps her. Shakes ran to the railway, standing in the middle of the rails, swinging his legs waving his CISM Exam Dumps arm, signaling the driver to stop moving forward. With a long and harsh brakes, the Bestexamview locomotive stopped. Driver head out of the window. You can not open here, she said to him. He asked her what it meant. She thought, he looked so young, actually driving such a large locomotive. Here Bestexamview is a crime scene, please turn off Bestexamview the engine. Miss, I did not see any crime. But Shakes did not have time to listen to him Examtestview long-winded. She was looking Bestexamview CISA dumps up at a gap in the barbed wire fence to the west of the viaduct. Not far from above is Bestexamview Eleven Street. One way of trying to bring a victim Examtestview here is to find that there is a way to stop the car at Eleven Street and drag the Bestexamview victim Cisco 210-260 Dumps across the narrow path to the edge of Cisco 210-260 Dumps the cliff. If you park CISM Exam Dumps your CISA dumps car on the 37th Street in the CISM Exam Dumps horizontal Examtestview direction, CISA dumps he may be seen by people in the windows of 20 apartments. The train, sir, just stop it here. I can not park the train here. Turn off the engine. Cisco 210-260 Dumps In this case Cisco 210-260 Dumps we can not turn off the train engine and it CISM Exam Dumps must be running. CISA dumps You call the dispatch or someone else to stop the train to Nankai. We can not do that. Get it right, sir, Examtestview Ive noticed the number of your CISA dumps car Bestexamview The car Youd better do Bestexamview it right away Shakes Examtestview roared. What do you want, Miss, give me a ticket But Emilio Shakus Examtestview climbed back up the steep hill again. Her poor knuckles crunched, CISM Exam Dumps her lips covered in lime, dirt, and her own sweat. She drilled through the gap she had found on the CISA dumps tracks and turned around to study the Javets Convention Center across Cisco 210-260 Dumps 11th Avenue and Examtestview across the street. The convention center is full CISM Exam Dumps of people today – there are participants and journalists. A Cisco 210-260 Dumps huge banner Cisco 210-260 Dumps reads Welcome United Nations Representative. Earlier Cisco 210-260 Dumps in the morning, however, there was still no one on the street, and the Bestexamview murderer could easily find a parking space in the street, before the people unwittingly moved the victim to the tracks. Shakespeare strode to Eleventh Street and Examtestview observed the six-lane main road, which is now full of traffic. Let it go She burst into the car sea, calmly cut off traffic Bestexamview on the north lane. CISM Exam Dumps Several drivers tried hard to force her to issue CISM Exam Dumps two tickets in a row. In the end, they dragged a few rubbish bins to the center of the road as roadblocks to ensure that these good citizens abided by the rules.

Adanya festival gagasan tersebut dapat dimaknai sebagai sebuah upaya penyadaran masyarakat dan peningkatan kapasitas atau kemampuan masyarakat untuk berpartisipasi. Pada tanggal 24 Maret 2018, komunitas Bagimu Trenggalek melakukan launching dan sosialisasi kepada seluruh stakeholder terkait termasuk perwakilan OPD di Kabupaten Trenggalek. Dalam acara tersebut, dilakukan penandantanganan MoU antara ketua Bagimu Trenggalek dengan Pemerintah Kabupaten Trenggalek yang saat itu diwakili oleh Kepala Bappedalitbang. Pada intinya isi Mou tersebut adalah pemerintah Kabupaten Trenggalek akan menindaklanjuti hasil festival gagasan dengan memasukkannya pada rencana pembangunan daerah khususnya Rencana Kerja Pemerintahan Daerah (RKPD). RKPD inilah yang akan menjadi cikal bakal APBD. Mou itulah yang menjadi garansi Pemerintah Kabupaten Trenggalek terhadap hasil partisipasi publik oleh festival gagasan.

Penyelenggaraan festival gagasan berhasil mengumpulkan 99 gagasan. Dari 99 gagasan tersebut diseleksi menjadi 18 gagasan. Kedelapanbelas gagasan tersebut kemudian dipaparkan dihadapan juri dan panelis pada tanggal 24 April 2018.  Adapun juri yang dilibatkan adalah Kepala Bappedalitbang, Sekretaris Inspektorat dan Bonari Nabonenar (budayawan). Sedangkan panelis yang akan menilai dan menguji gagasan diantaranya: 1) Nandang Suherman – Perkumpulan Inisiatif Bandung; 2) Dakelan – Fitra Jatim; 3) Sulung Muna Rimbawan – Ombudsman Jatim; 4) M. Saiful Rohman – Dwily Farm; dan 5) Soeripto – CSO Trenggalek.  Dari hasil penilaian juri dan panelis maka terpilih 9 gagasan terbaik yang terdiri dari 3 gagasan bertema ekonomi kerakyatan, 3 gagasan bertema pelayanan publik, 1 gagasan bertema peningkatan PAD, dan 2 gagasan bertema reformasi birokrasi. Sembilan puluh gagasan lainnya yang tidak terpilih bukan berarti tidak baik. Kesembilan gagasan yang terpilih merupakan gagasan yang paling mungkin untuk diimplementasi oleh Pemerintah Kabupaten Trenggalek, memberikan nilai manfaat, ada unsur kebaruan dan sesuai dengan permasalahan yang dihadapi. Menurut Abe (2005) pada dasarnya seluruh pendapat masyarakat tidak harus diakomodasi secara keseluruhan. Perlu dilakukan pemilahan mana yang benar-benar menjadi kebutuhan atau hanya keinginan semata.

Berdasarkan hasil festival gagasan tersebut, Bappedalitbang mengundang OPD terkait yang akan melaksanakan kesembilan gagasan terpilih pada tanggal 18 Juli 2018. Acara tersebut adalah bentuk komitmen Pemerintah Kabupaten Trenggalek untuk menjamin hasil partisipasi akan dilaksanakan oleh OPD terkait. OPD yang terkait dengan 9 gagasan terbaik ada 17 OPD. Kesimpulan dari rapat tersebut adalah sebagian besar gagasan sudah dilakukan oleh OPD namun perlu penajaman pelaksanaan kegiatan agar lebih berjalan optimal. Beberapa item dalam gagasan ada yang tidak dapat dilaksanakan karena terbentur dengan peraturan perundang-undangan atau belum sesuai dengan kemampuan teknis OPD. Kesembilan gagasan tersebut juga akan dimasukkan dalam Renstra OPD dan RKPD perubahan atau RKPD tahun 2019.

Diperlukan kerjasama antar berbagai stakeholder dalam pembangunan daerah. Setelah komunitas masyarakat tergerak untuk meningkatkan kesadaran dan kemampuan masyarakat dalam berpartisipasi maka sudah selayaknya pemerintah daerah mengupayakan membuka ruang seluas-luasnya untuk menampung aspirasi masyarakat serta yang terpenting adalah melakukan penjaminan hasil partisipasi (garansi) agar kesan formalitas partisipatif di masa lalu tidak akan terulang di masa mendatang.

Tinggalkan Balasan

Alamat email Anda tidak akan dipublikasikan. Ruas yang wajib ditandai *

Situs ini menggunakan Akismet untuk mengurangi spam. Pelajari bagaimana data komentar Anda diproses.